Big Chuck Says: “Help Me Solve a Local Mystery!!”

The City of Oneonta historian, Mark Simonson, came on my show this morning for his monthly visit and we set the "Wayback Machine" to May, 1956.  During our discussion we unearthed a BIG mystery about the Unadilla Diner.  Something doesn't sound right to me, so take a listen and please SOLVE THIS MYSTERY FOR ME!